The disaster at the Digital Areopagus continues.
Having silenced all the interesting voices- well, not all- the site is collapsing, at least as measured in volume of comments and contributors.
Because the site is premised upon a false assumption.
The site desires to excommunicate all those who passionately believe the difference between atheism and Catholicism matters, and matters enough to fight for.
Brandon has failed because Brandon is an Abandon-The-Bastions neo-Catholic.
The world has already rejected this Neo-Catholicism, and why not?
It is a disgraceful perversion of the Faith; its triumph in the post-conciliar age has coincided with the most awful collapse of Catholic Faith and morals in history.
By their fruits you shall know them.
I have a contrary hypothesis.
I believe we need, not a Digital Areopagus, but a Digital Lepanto.
I would be willing to join with atheists and agnostics in financially contributing to a site, the moderation of which would be in the hands of a council of contributors, each of whom contribute equally financially toward the upkeep of the site, and all of whom must agree in order for any Memoryholing of any kind to take place.
Brandon's idea was great.
His execution was profoundly poor.
This offer stands.